Why Toddlers Sometimes Prefer One Parent Over the Other — And How to Handle It as a Couple

As a parent, there’s nothing quite like the feeling of being needed and loved by your child. But what happens when that affection shifts, and your toddler starts preferring one parent over the other? It can feel like a punch to the gut,  especially when it’s not you they’re reaching for. If you’ve ever found yourself feeling left out or hurt by your child’s sudden preference, know that you’re not alone. This behavior is common, especially during toddlerhood, and is often a temporary phase in your child’s emotional development. Understanding why it happens and how to navigate it together as a couple can strengthen your bond and help you both weather this tricky phase with patience, teamwork, and a bit of humor.

Why toddlers sometimes prefer one parent over the other...

It's’s an experience many parents face: your toddler seems to want the other parent more than you. The first time it happens, it can be tough. You may feel hurt, confused, or even rejected when your child pushes you away and reaches for the other parent. But before jumping to conclusions, it’s important to understand that this behavior is normal and a part of your child’s emotional development. With patience, communication, and teamwork, parents can navigate this phase together.

Understanding the Toddler’s Mindset.

Toddlers are navigating a world full of changes as they develop emotionally, cognitively, and socially. During this time, they form strong attachments, particularly to their parents. However, these attachments can shift frequently, causing them to prefer one parent over the other at different times.

Related post:  Attachment parenting, a heartfelt guide to raising resilient and confident kids 

The Need for Security

For many toddlers, their attachment to one parent at a given moment is all about seeking comfort and security. Toddlers are still learning to manage their emotions, so they naturally seek out the parent they associate with calmness or reassurance. It’s not that they love one parent more than the other; it’s simply part of their developmental phase.

Take Sarah, for example. She was shocked when her 2-year-old daughter, Emma, started showing a strong preference for her father, Alex. "It broke my heart," Sarah shares. "I’d spend the day with Emma, but when she was upset, she’d scream for her dad, not me." But after reflecting, Sarah realized that during a period of illness, Alex had stepped in to care for Emma more frequently. Emma had started associating Alex with comfort during difficult moments, particularly bedtime.

Emotional Attachment and Preferences.

The truth is, toddlers often go through phases where they prefer one parent over the other. This is normal. It could be based on something as simple as who handled a particular routine, or it could be due to a deeper emotional need they’re trying to fulfill. As Sarah discovered, Emma's preference wasn’t permanent, but a result of the time she spent with Alex when Sarah was unwell.

Why Does This Happen?

There are many reasons a toddler might gravitate toward one parent more than the other. It’s important for both parents to understand these reasons to avoid feelings of rejection.

1. Separation Anxiety: Toddlers often become attached to one parent, especially after a period of absence or separation. If one parent has been away for work or a trip, the child may seek the comfort of the other parent who has been present.

2. Routine and Familiarity: Children thrive on routine. If one parent is typically in charge of certain tasks, like feeding or bedtime, the child might start associating that parent with comfort and security.

3. Temperament: Children have different personalities, and they may feel more at ease with the parent whose temperament aligns with theirs. A calm toddler might prefer a more patient, gentle parent, while a more energetic child may seek out a more active or playful parent.

4. Parental Stress or Absence: If one parent is under stress or unavailable, the child might cling to the parent they perceive as more stable or emotionally available.

How to Navigate This Phase as a Couple.

It can be difficult for the parent who feels left out when a toddler seems to prefer the other. But there are ways for parents to handle this phase and work together as a team.

1. Communicate Openly.

When a child seems to prefer one parent, it’s essential for both parents to communicate their feelings. Share your thoughts honestly with each other, and express how the situation makes you feel. Sarah, for example, confided in Alex about her feelings of rejection, and Alex reassured her that Emma’s preference wasn’t a reflection of their parenting abilities, just a temporary phase. This open communication helped Sarah feel supported and reassured.

2. Work Together, Not Against Each Other.

Instead of viewing the situation as a competition, see it as an opportunity to work as a team. Remember that your child’s preference doesn’t mean they love one parent more than the other. Emily, even though she initially felt left out when her son Luke preferred his dad at bedtime, began focusing on creating her own special moments with Luke, like afternoon walks. This allowed both parents to bond with Luke, even if his preference for one parent shifted over time.

3. Stay Involved Even When You’re Not the Preferred Parent.

It can be tempting to pull back when your toddler doesn’t seem to want you. But it’s important to stay involved in their routine and continue showing up. John, whose son Luke preferred him during bedtime, ensured that Emily remained involved in other activities, like mealtime. This consistency reassured Luke that both parents were still equally important.

4. Don’t Take It Personally.

It’s easy to feel rejected, but remember that your toddler’s behavior is not a reflection of your worth as a parent. Their preferences are part of their emotional development, and this phase will pass. Sarah learned to accept that Emma’s attachment to Alex wasn’t about her; it was simply about the unique bond Emma had formed with him at that time. By letting go of personal hurt, Sarah was able to approach the situation with patience and understanding.

5. Consistency is Key.

While your child may show a preference for one parent, maintaining a consistent routine is crucial. Consistency helps toddlers feel secure, knowing that both parents are involved in their daily life. Whether it's playing together or sticking to familiar routines, consistency reassures your child that both parents are there for them, even when they may seem to prefer one over the other.

In conclusion:

Seeing your toddler favor one parent over the other can be tough, but it’s important to remember that it’s a normal part of child development. This phase will pass, and with patience, understanding, and open communication, both parents can manage it together. Keep in mind that your child’s love for you is not defined by who they prefer at a given moment. By staying involved, supporting each other, and keeping the bigger picture in mind, you’ll help your child feel loved and secure, no matter which parent they prefer at any given time.